Zeppelin tiene 3 votos genuinos. El resto elige Beatle o anti Beatle
Confeso fanatico de los Beatles no puedo negar la grandeza de Zeppelin. Lo que lograron transmitir con temas como Stairway to Heaven o When the levee breaks es impresionante. Ahora, sigo queriendo que ganen The Beatles.
Un poco de la grandeza demostrada de Zeppelin
[SPOILER] VH1 100 greatest artists of all time list
-
The Beatles
-
Michael Jackson
-
Led Zeppelin
-
Rolling Stones
-
Bob Dylan
-
Jimi Hendrix
-
Prince
-
Elvis Presley
-
James Brown
-
Stevie Wonder
-
Bob Marley
-
David Bowie
-
The Who
-
Nirvana
-
The Beach Boys
-
Madonna
-
Queen
-
Pink Floyd
-
U2
-
Marvin Gaye
-
Bruce Springsteen
-
The Clash
-
AC/DC
-
The Velvet Underground
-
Chuck Berry
-
Neil Young
-
Aretha Franklin
-
Elton John
-
Radiohead
-
Aerosmith
-
John Lennon
-
Black Sabbath
-
Guns N’ Roses
-
Tina Turner
-
Johnny Cash
-
Paul McCartney
-
Fleetwood Mac
-
Sly & The Family Stone
-
The Kinks
-
The Police
-
Van Halen
-
Metallica
-
Ray Charles
-
Joni Mitchell
-
Al Green
-
Ramones
-
Jay-Z
-
Rage Against the Machine
-
Parliament-Funkadelic
-
Sade
-
Billy Joel
-
Beyonce
-
Little Richard
-
Public Enemy
-
Peter Gabriel
-
KISS
-
Iggy & the Stooges
-
Cheap Trick
-
Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers
-
Whitney Houston
-
Cream
-
Genesis
-
Notorious B.I.G.
-
Talking Heads
-
The Doors
-
Justin Timberlake
-
Coldplay
-
Otis Redding
-
Tupac Shakur
-
Def Leppard
-
R.E.M.
-
Janis Joplin
-
Van Morrison
-
The Cure
-
Rush
-
Run-DMC
-
Lynyrd Skynyrd
-
Judas Priest
-
Eminem
-
Mary J. Blige
-
ABBA
-
Steely Dan
-
Earth Wind and Fire
-
Curtis Mayfield
-
The Band
-
N.W.A.
-
George Michael
-
Bee Gees
-
Beastie Boys
-
Elvis Costello
-
Green Day
-
LL Cool J
-
Pearl Jam
-
Mariah Carey
-
OutKast
-
Journey
-
Pretenders
-
Depeche Mode
-
Hall & Oates
-
Alicia Keys[/SPOILER]
No se gente que problema hay con que tenga 0 mensajes (ahora 1) y vote en una encuesta publica en la que no hay restricciones, nada mas leo el foro para informarme por eso no tengo mensajes, y vote a zeppelin porque me gusta y amo su musica.
Si quieren saber si soy un fake, fijense desde cuando estoy registrado y que este no es mi primer movimiento en el foro. Saludos
The Doors en el puesto 65 ? Un arafue mas grande que una casa para esa lista
Aca esta la raiz del tema, no es para generar discordia, arriba zep y little richard y los beatles y todos.
jaja justo antes de justin timberlake…!! :roll: bizarro
Es un tributo a Little Richard quedate tranquilo… :twisted::twisted::twisted::twisted:
Igual, más allá de los votos, el fraude lo cometió Zeppelin hace años ya.:mrgreen:
Jajaja :mrgreen:
Acá está la lista de la Rolling Stone
[SPOILER]Rolling Stone 100 greatest artists of all time list
- The Beatles - Makes sense. Some of the most influential albums of all time are the works of these lads. What else can you say?
- Bob Dylan - I could argue with this one. He’s a legend, but number 2?
- Elvis Presley - Very successful, the king of rock n roll of course, but he was very controlled by his manager.
- Rolling Stones - Often called ‘Anti-Beatles’, definitely top 5
- Chuck Berry - Probably invented Rock n Roll. Deserves to be here.
- Jimi Hendrix - First guitar god, I believe. Revolutionary player
- James Brown - Godfather of soul, is it? Great showman
- Little Richard - American Rock & Roll/R & B singer and pianist
- Aretha Franklin - I think she was the first woman to be inducted into the rock n roll hall of fame. I’ll look that up later.
- Ray Charles - American R&B singer and pianist
- Bob Marley - Jamaican reggae singer
- The Beach Boys - Some of the catchiest songs I ever heard.
- Buddy Holly - Tragic death. One of the first to use a solid-body electric guitar.
- Led Zeppelin - Possibly the ‘fathers of heavy metal’, but some might argue that Black Sabbath is.
- Stevie Wonder - American soul singer. Plays many different instruments, and has won 22 grammy awards
- Sam Cooke - A founder of soul music.
- Muddy Waters - ‘Father of Chicago Blues’
- Marvin Gaye - ‘The Prince of Motown’.
- The Velvet Underground - American rock band, formed in 1965. Regarded as highly influencial in the rise to punk-rock, and alt-rock.
- Bo Diddley - Legendary R&B singer. Known as the ‘Originator’
- Otis Redding - You might not know him, but you’ve probably heard ‘Sittin’ on the dock of a bay’.
- U2 - The Joshua Tree was one of my favourite albums
- Bruce Springsteen - Born in the USA was overplayed. Good to see him make music again.
- Jerry Lee Lewis - ‘Great Balls of Fire’ was his greatest hit, and one of my favs
- Fats Domino - Rock & Roll pianist
- The Ramones - Regarded as the first punk-rock group
- Nirvana - I swear, RS magazine has a hard-on for these guys. They put Kurt Cobain at #12 on their ‘Greatest Guitarists of All Time’ list, and now this.
- Prince - ‘Purple Rain’ is one of my favourite albums. He’s also an icon in style
- The Who - Should be higher. Rock artists still try to sound like them
- The Clash - English punk-rock band from the 70’s
- Johnny Cash - The ‘Man in Black’. Should be higher, since he’s the equivalent of Elvis, except country. The only country singer I like
- Smokey Robinson & The Miracles - American R&B group
- The Everly Brothers - Country/Rock Duo
- Neil Young - Candadian singer-songwriter. Influencial in grunge, though typically labeled folk/rock
- Michael Jackson - Would be higher if he wasn’t wacko. Thriller was the best-selling album of all time
- Madonna - I don’t like her music, but she could still be higher. The ‘Queen of Pop’
- Roy Orbison - American singer-songwriter. Sang ‘Oh, Pretty Woman’
- John Lennon - Liked him in the Beatles, not as a solo artist. Imagine was a great song, however
- David Bowie - Icon in music, as well as style
- Simon and Garfunkel - Should be in the top twenty, in my opinion. If you haven’t heard of them, you need to get some education
- The Doors - I’d put them top 30, but this is alright
- Van Morrison - ‘Van the Man’. Sang ‘Brown Eyed Girl’.
- Sly and the Family Stone - American funk band
- Public Enemy - Not a chance. I’d say about 80, maybe
- The Byrds - American rock group
- Janis Joplin - American singer-songwriter
- Patti Smith - The ‘Godmother of Punk’
- Run-DMC - Biggest act in hip-hop throughout the 80’s
- Elton John - Should be higher. Not a huge fan, but I can appreciate his talent
- The Band - Canadian rock band. They backed Ronnie Hawkins, and Bob Dylan
- Howlin’ Wolf - Blues singer. Another attempt to cater to the R&B genre. Every prolific classic R&B singer made it onto this list in some random order. They put Muddy Waters ahead of Marvin Gaye. Come on
- Allman Brothers Band - Southern-rock band
- Eric Clapton - English blues-rock guitarist
- Dr. Dre - Has numerous Grammys for rapping and producing
- Grateful Dead - American rock band
- Parliament/Funkadelic - African-American soul band
- Aerosmith - American hard rock band
- Sex Pistols - One of the first punk bands. Definitely one of the most prolific
- Louis Jordan - Jazz musician. Not familiar with his works
- Joni Mitchell - Canadian singer-songwriter
- Tina Turner - American singer and entertainer
- Etta James - American R&B singer. Sang ‘At Last’. Should be top 90s if anything at all
- Phil Spector - He’s a producer. Why is he on here?
- The Kinks - English rock group
- Al Green - American gospel singer
- Cream - '60’s British rock band. Considered to be the first ‘supergroup’
- The Temptations - American R&B vocal group
- Jackie Wilson - R&B singer
- Carl Perkins - ‘The King of Rockabilly’
- The Police - Sold over 50 million albums world-wide. Highest paid musical act of 2008. Biggest ego of a bassist frontman
- Frank Zappa - American composer. Phenomenal guitarist
- AC/DC - They’ve had countless hits, and are one of the most popular bands around. I’m surprised RS didn’t place them higher-glad they didn’t
- Radiohead - Glad to see them gettin’ some love, but they were placed ahead of some great legends. Maybe a few years down the road I would put them here
- Hank Williams - Country singing legend
- The Eagles - Could be higher. Their greatest hits album was the 2nd greatest selling album of all time
- The Shirelles - Girl group in the 60’s. The first to get a #1 single on the Billboard 100. I would exlude them based on their lack of longevity
- Beastie Boys - Jewish hiphop group. Never would have guessed they’d be successful, but they were
- The Stooges - Highly influencial in punk-rock
- The Four Tops - American R&B quartet. Are noted for having a baritone for a lead singer(stubbs)
- Elvis Costello - English musician, singer-songwriter
- The Drifters - American R&B vocal group
- Eminem - Has many awards, including an Academy award for ‘best original song’ for 2002’s ‘Lose Yourself’
- N.W.A. - Gangsta-rap group from the eighties. Dr. Dre and Ice Cube were in this group
- James Taylor - American singer/songwriter and guitarist from Boston
- Black Sabbath - RS never really liked Black Sabbath. If memory serves me correctly, their first review of Sabbath went something like ‘Should they even exist?..’. I would place them in the top 40 at least
- Tupac Shakur - Rap artist. The first to have an album go to #1 while in jail.
- Gram Parsons - Country singer. Died at age 26
- Miles Davis - Jazz trumpet player
- The Yardbirds - English rock group. Introduced us to Clapton, Page, and Beck
- Carlos Santana - Solo guitar player. His band has consisted of about 40 people over the years
- Ricky Nelson - American singer with over 50 Hot 100 hits
- Guns n Roses - ‘Appetite for Destruction’ was the best thing they ever did. Too bad they weren’t consistent
- Booker T. and the MG’s - Instrumental soul band. One of the first inter-racial groups
- Nine Inch Nails - Trent Reznor is Nine Inch Nails. He’s pretty much the only member
- Lynyrd Skynyrd - American southern rock band
- Martha and the Vandellas - Female R&B group
- Diana Ross and the Supremes - Popular female singing group of the 60’s
- Roxy Music - English rock group from the 70’s. Not top 100 material
- Curtis Mayfield - American soul singer
- Lee ‘Scratch’ Perry - Influencial figure in Reggae music[/SPOILER]
jaja no se que es peor si la de la Rolling Stone o la de VH1… pauperrimas.
si,pero igual debe ser complicado hacer un ranking con tantas bandas y sobre todo mezclando los generos… y hay que ver quien vota, y bajo que criterio! …aunque hay cosas inaceptables… zappa puesto 71…
See, en la RS Zeppelin no entra ni en el TOP 10, una vergüenza
Pero ambas coinciden en algo…
Son horribles, ni una de mis bandas favoritas aparece.
jaja, si, igual esas listas siempre me parecieron cualquiera… quieren abarcar " mucho " pero no abarcan nada. me encanta aretha franklin pero no se la puede meter dentro de un top 10 donde estan los bitles, dylan, pocho la pantera y el soundtrack de nubeluz… no tiene sentido. odio la rolling stone!
Falto rafaga en la lista! puesto numero 5. jajaja :mrgreen:
Cuando ví a Gilmour en el número 82, perdió toda credibilidad.
no me acuerdo de que revista era, pero en una encuesta de mejores guitarristas Cobain estaba dentro del top 10. :lol:
Poner a gilmour en ese puesto es un crimen jaja
bueno, en el puesto 12.
los redactores de la RS van en busca del peyote mas eficiente antes de hacer listas.